A Universal TPS Beam Model for Varian Truebeam SRS Treatment out-Performs Local Center-Specific Beam Models
Abstract
Purpose
Treatment planning system (TPS) beam modelling is identified as the largest cause of independent dosimetry audit failure. This study aims to develop and validate a universal beam model (UBM) specific to single-iso multi-target (SIMT) stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) on Varian TrueBeam to mitigate risk of local TPS beam modelling errors.
Methods
Percentage depth-dose at 10cm (PDD10), Eclipse dose calibration factor, high-definition multi-leaf collimator (HDMLC) dosimetric leaf gap (DLG)/transmission, and small-field output factors were measured on Varian TrueBeam by an international consortium of 11 centers to assess dosimetric equivalence. Center-averaged measurements, together with Varian reference beam data, were then used to configure a 6FFF AcurosXB dose-to-medium UBM in the Eclipse v18.1 TPS. To validate UBM accuracy, nine non-coplanar SIMT-SRS VMAT plans (target diameters: 5-20mm) were produced and calculated (1mm grid size) on a virtual 20cm diameter spherical water phantom (TPSUBM). Five of the centers calculated the plans with fixed monitor units (TPSinstitute) and measured the dose within the planned virtual phantom using an electronic portal imaging device (EPID) via EPID-to-dose conversion.
Results
The range for PDD10, Eclipse dose calibration factor, HDMLC DLG and HDMLC transmission measured 0.630-0.639, 0.924-0.936Gy/100MU, 0.29-0.84mm and 0.98-1.04% respectively. The coefficient of variation in output factors measured < 2.0% for fields down to 5x5mm and < 2.5% for PTV D99%, Dmean and Dmax for the dynamic SIMT-SRS plan deliveries. For plan verification measurement, percentage difference in PTV Dmean was on average 2.2% (range: -0.5 to 6.6%) for TPSinstitute, which reduced to 0.4% (range: -1.6 to 3.2%) for TPSUBM. Similarly, global 5%/1mm gamma pass rates improved on average by 0.5% (range: -2.3 to +5.2%) utilising TPSUBM. Significantly, four of the five centers showed benefit using the UBM.
Conclusion
Dosimetric equivalence of Variance TrueBeam makes feasible the application of a UBM for safe and accurate SIMT-SRS dose-calculation.